When Innovation Isn’t Enough: Why Great Medical Ideas Fail (Part 1)
If you follow this blog, you already know that I consider it fundamental to learn from errors—especially from others’ mistakes or unsuccessful experiments. Today, I’d like to explore why a medical innovation, even if effective and potentially lifesaving, might not succeed. I’ll discuss the factors that underpin the success of innovation. Let’s begin with one example of medical innovation that failed to gain traction. A Very Old Example In the past, scurvy was a deadly disease, especially among sailors. In fact, in 1497, the crew of Vasco da Gama—the first to sail around the Cape of Good Hope—was decimated. At the time, scurvy killed more sailors than any other cause. In 1601, English captain James Lancaster conducted an experiment to test the hypothesis that lemon juice could prevent scurvy. He…









